Blog

Most parents begin estate planning assuming that fairness means an equal split among their children. Once they think through each child’s actual circumstances, that assumption often does not hold up.

A child who is financially secure may not need the same support as a sibling who is still working toward stability. A child who has spent years working in the family business occupies a different position than a sibling who built a career elsewhere. In situations like these, an equal split can end up working against what a parent actually wants for their children.

At Sessa & Dorsey, we help families think through what an unequal inheritance actually requires. That means coordinating with your financial and tax advisors to structure a plan that reflects each child’s real circumstances, while protecting the family relationships that an inheritance is ultimately meant to support.

When Equal Does Not Mean Fair

Unequal inheritances are more common than many families realize. Research using the University of Michigan’s Health and Retirement Study found that more than one-third of parents with wills plan to divide their estates unequally among their children, often for reasons that have little to do with favoritism.

There are several common reasons parents choose this path rather than splitting assets evenly:

• One child has achieved significant financial independence, while another has greater ongoing need
• One child is deeply involved in the family business and stands to inherit a controlling or majority interest in it, while siblings pursued other careers
• One child took on a significant caregiving role for a parent later in life
• One child has already received substantial financial support during the parent’s lifetime, such as help with a home purchase or business funding

In each of these situations, an equal split can work against the parent’s actual intent. Treating two children identically when their circumstances, contributions, or needs differ significantly can produce a result that feels less fair than an intentional, unequal plan.

Approaches to Balancing an Unequal Inheritance

Unequal does not have to mean uneven in spirit. A parent can treat children differently on paper while still pursuing an outcome that feels balanced overall:

• Life insurance: A policy can provide a source of funds for a child who is receiving less of another asset, without requiring that asset itself to be split
• Offsetting with other assets: Investment accounts, real estate, or other holdings of comparable value can be left to a sibling to balance a larger share given to another child
• Accounting for prior gifts: Significant financial support already given to one child during the parent’s lifetime, such as a down payment or an unpaid loan, can be factored into that child’s share so the overall plan still feels balanced

These approaches let a parent’s actual wishes, rather than a simple even split, drive the plan, while still giving each child a result that reflects the family’s full financial picture.

Alongside these approaches, the reasoning behind them should also be put in writing. Courts can treat an unexplained gap between siblings as an oversight rather than a deliberate choice, which gives an unhappy heir grounds to contest the will. A will or trust that states the reasoning, even briefly, removes that ambiguity.

Structuring Each Child’s Inheritance to Fit Their Circumstances

How an asset is structured for each child can matter as much as how much that child receives:

• A child with greater financial need may be better served by assets held in a trust, with distributions made over time rather than as an outright lump sum
• A financially independent child may be better served by a more straightforward distribution
• The right structure depends on the child receiving it, since what protects one child’s inheritance is not always what serves another’s

These decisions are where comprehensive estate planning adds the most value. A properly structured unequal inheritance can reduce tax exposure, protect assets from creditors or poor financial decisions, and ensure each child receives their inheritance in a form suited to their actual circumstances, rather than a one-size-fits-all distribution.

Planning for the Family Business

A family business raises planning questions that go beyond who inherits it. A child who has spent years working inside the business has typically sacrificed other career opportunities to do so, and has also developed knowledge of the business that a sibling outside of it does not have. Recognizing that contribution through a controlling or majority interest in the business is often a more accurate reflection of each child’s role than an equal ownership split would be.

A well-structured succession plan, built through a comprehensive estate plan, should address:

• How the business should be valued
• Any existing or future agreements affecting how it can be transitioned or transferred
• Whether siblings outside the business should hold any ongoing interest in it
• How the timing of the transfer affects the business’s stability during a period when its leadership is already changing

Especially when the business represents a significant share of the family’s wealth, getting these mechanics right protects both the business and the inheritance built around it.

Talking to Your Children About the Plan

Family relationships matter as much as the financial details of a plan. Children who learn about an unequal distribution only after a parent’s death, without any context for the decision, are more likely to read it as a judgment rather than a thoughtful response to their actual circumstances.

Sharing the reasoning while everyone is still living, even in general terms, can prevent that misunderstanding before it takes hold. For more on how fiduciary decisions intersect with family dynamics, see our post on how to protect your family from estate planning disputes before they start.

Building a Plan That Reflects Your Family

An unequal inheritance can still be a fair one, provided it reflects each child’s actual financial position, contributions, and needs rather than a default assumption that equal shares are the only equitable option.

If you are considering an unequal inheritance or a family business succession plan, contact Sessa & Dorsey at (443) 589-5600 or schedule a consultation.